Who this checklist is for

I'm the procurement coordinator at a 360-person food processing plant in the Midwest. I manage roughly $4M a year in vendor spend across about 30 suppliers, and I report to both the operations director and our CFO. When we replaced our aging ammonia system in 2023, engineering owned the technical scope. I owned everything else — the RFQ process, the quote comparison, the contract paperwork, and about forty-two phone calls that got the system running on time.

Look, I'm not an engineer. I don't size compressors, and I don't want to. But I've learned enough to ask the right questions before we commit $400K to something we can't un-buy.

Here's the 7-step checklist I use now for any industrial refrigeration system sourcing project. It doesn't require an engineering degree. If you've been handed "find us a new industrial refrigeration system," this is what I'd do in your shoes.

Step 1: Nail down the cooling load and refrigerant before you email anyone

The temptation is to start by calling vendors. Don't. Start with your own engineering team (or a consulting engineer) and get two numbers on paper: the design cooling load in tons or kW, and the refrigerant — ammonia (R-717), CO2 (R-744), glycol, or an HFC blend.

Why this matters in plain terms: ammonia systems above 10,000 lbs of charge fall under OSHA's Process Safety Management standard (29 CFR 1910.119). That's a compliance regime with documented hazard analysis, mechanical integrity inspections, and incident investigation requirements. Your vendor selection just got more complicated because of a refrigerant decision — so make that decision first, not last.

ASHRAE Standard 15 sets the safety code for refrigeration systems, and IIAR publishes the design and operating standards specific to ammonia. If a prospective industrial refrigeration system manufacturer can't tell you how their design meets those, that's a signal.

Step 2: Decide which role each vendor actually plays

"Manufacturer," "distributor," and "EPC" get used interchangeably in this market. They're not the same, and the difference decides how much of your project you're outsourcing.

  • Manufacturer-direct: builds the equipment, sometimes handles the design, often insists on approved installers.
  • Industrial refrigeration system distributor: stocks or brokers equipment, provides local service, usually not the design authority.
  • EPC / design-build: owns design, install, and commissioning end to end, at a higher markup and with less price transparency per line item.

The question isn't which model is best. It's which model fits what you don't have in-house. If your maintenance team can't service ammonia (most can't — and shouldn't), you need a service relationship, not just an equipment vendor.

Step 3: Require a written design basis before any quote crosses your desk

This is the step nearly everyone skips. It's also where I lost three months on our first round of quotes.

I said "system design." They heard "equipment list." Result: the quotes came in listing compressors and vessels — no pipe sizing, no relief valve calculations, no plot plan. Nothing that could actually be installed. We started over.

A real industrial refrigeration system design basis, at minimum, includes:

  • Refrigeration load calculation with assumptions spelled out
  • Piping and instrumentation diagrams (P&IDs)
  • Equipment sizing and relief valve calculations
  • A plot plan showing physical fit inside your existing footprint
  • Utility requirements — power, water, drain

If a vendor can't produce this before pricing, they're pricing a wish list. Don't accept it.

Step 4: Ask each supplier what they don't make

This is the question that separates a credible vendor from a marketing brochure.

Ammonia compressors (screw or reciprocating) are one market. ASME-certified pressure vessels are another. Control systems are a third. No single industrial refrigeration system manufacturer builds all three in-house at scale — and the ones who claim to usually subcontract half the scope quietly.

Ask directly: "What parts of this system do you manufacture, and what parts do you source or subcontract?" A good supplier answers in detail. The vaguer ones change the subject.

The vendor who told me "we don't do controls — here's who you should talk to" earned my trust for everything else they quoted. The one who claimed to do all of it was the one who subbed out three subsystems and didn't mention it until the schedule slipped.

That's the expertise boundary test in practical terms. A specialist who knows where their scope ends is a safer bet than a generalist who's never drawn a line.

Step 5: Lock install and after-hours service coverage in the RFQ

Two questions belong in the RFQ, not buried in a service appendix you read three days before signing:

  1. Who is on the install crew, and are they employees or subcontractors?
  2. What's the guaranteed response time for an ammonia-related call after 6pm?

Cold storage doesn't wait for business hours. Our compressors run 24/7, and a two-hour response window vs. "next business day" is the difference between a $3K repair and a $60K product loss.

Ammonia service techs need EPA Section 608 certification under the Clean Air Act and, depending on your state, specific ammonia handling credentials. Ask for the names and certifications of the people who will actually be on site — not the names on the sales team.

Step 6: Run the compliance and paperwork audit before you sign anything

This is the boring step, and I've watched it sink a project at a former employer.

Before any purchase order:

  • Verify insurance certificates — general liability, workers comp, auto.
  • Confirm they can issue a standard invoice with a W-9 on file and a PO reference field. (I've had to fix this after the fact — a handwritten receipt cost us two weeks of finance back-and-forth.)
  • If the system falls under PSM, confirm they'll supply documentation in the format your safety manager needs — updated P&IDs, relief valve sizing records, mechanical integrity documentation.
  • Confirm refrigerant handling compliance — EPA Section 608 is non-negotiable for ammonia and HFC techs alike.

I dodged a bullet on our 2023 project. The vendor we almost chose quoted 18% lower, but when I asked for their standard PSM documentation package, they didn't have one. Our safety manager would have had to build the entire process safety documentation from scratch. That's a six-figure line item no one had budgeted for.

Step 7: Write commissioning and handover into the contract, not the punch list

Every refrigeration contract I've reviewed includes equipment, install, and "startup." Fewer than half include the parts that determine whether you can actually operate the thing:

  • Documented operator training — hours, format, and who attends. IIAR publishes guidance on required training; ask the vendor to commit to matching it.
  • Updated P&IDs and as-built drawings
  • O&M manuals in both paper and electronic form
  • Warranty response SLAs with named financial penalties
  • A written list of PSM documentation updates the vendor will provide

If it's not in the contract, it isn't happening. I've had vendors promise training verbally and then present a one-hour walkthrough on the final invoice as "training."

Common mistakes I've made or watched others make

  • Calling vendors before defining the load. You'll get five incompatible quotes and a month of sorting them.
  • Letting one vendor define the scope. That's how you end up with a system designed around one supplier's product line.
  • Skipping the service coverage clause. The install is one-time. The service relationship is ten years minimum.
  • Not asking "what don't you do?" A vendor without boundaries usually doesn't have specialties either.

The best sourcing outcome I've had wasn't the lowest quote. It was the ammonia system vendor who told us upfront which two subsystems they'd source from partners — and got our written approval on both partners before the contract. That's a specialist being honest about where their capability ends. It's also the reason that project landed on schedule.

Same rules apply whether you're replacing a 20-year-old system or quoting a new industrial ammonia refrigeration system for a greenfield cold storage build. Define the load. Test the boundary. Get it in writing.